Unbiased My Excellent Pet Cat Meals Evaluate

Kirsten McCarthy / Cats.com

Gently cooked recent cat meals frozen on the peak of freshness and delivered to the doorstep—that’s what My Excellent Pet presents. However what units this model aside from different recent cat meals manufacturers and pet meals supply providers? Discover out on this detailed overview.

The Cats.com Normal—Score My Excellent Pet on What Issues

We’ve analyzed My Excellent Pet and graded it in response to the Cats.com normal, evaluating the model on species-appropriateness, ingredient high quality, product selection, worth, buyer expertise, and recall historical past. Right here’s the way it charges in every of these six key areas.

We give My Excellent Pet a 50 out of 60 ranking or an A- grade.

Why Belief Cats.com

Earlier than testing cat meals merchandise for overview, we spend quite a lot of time researching the model. We need to get a really feel for the model’s historical past, manufacturing requirements, and sourcing insurance policies, in addition to buyer satisfaction with the corporate and the merchandise themselves. To this finish, we learn buyer testimonials on the model’s web site and every other retail websites the place the merchandise are offered (and third-party overview websites, the place relevant).

With a agency understanding of the model in thoughts, we order a number of merchandise for in-home testing with our very personal cats. All merchandise are bought at full retail worth and totally evaluated with none direct affect or involvement from the model. Through the testing course of, we observe sensible particulars reminiscent of packaging and delivery pace in addition to options of the merchandise. We depend on our cats to supply their opinions on the meals itself.

About My Excellent Pet

My Excellent Pet was based in 2007 by Karen Neola. After spending 25 years as a company skilled in science, engineering, and R&D, Neola’s life modified path when she misplaced her yellow Lab, Hunter. Only a few weeks later, the most important pet meals recall in historical past was introduced.

The announcement impressed Neola to revise her plans to retire from the company world to deal with having fun with life together with her pets and giving again to her neighborhood. As an alternative, she devoted herself to researching the pet meals business and located her ardour in educating pet house owners about the right way to make extra knowledgeable decisions associated to their pets’ diets.

Neola’s ardour rapidly developed right into a full-scale operation, ensuing within the launch of My Excellent Pet.  My Excellent Pet claims to be the primary firm to make “cooked frozen” pet meals commercially out there. The corporate stays independently owned and operated, claiming integrity as its No. 1 core worth.

Sourcing and Manufacturing

All My Excellent Pet meals are made with components suitable for eating and manufactured in FDA-inspected human meals amenities. As such, they meet the definition of “human-grade.” All meat components are baked individually on the minimal cooking temperature beneficial by the FDA then mixed with uncooked greens and floor right into a superb texture.

As soon as the merchandise are cooked and blended, the dietary supplements are added to the totally cooled product. The meals is then divided into 4-ounce parts and individually packaged earlier than being frozen. This eliminates the necessity for preservatives and maintains the freshness of each the cooked and uncooked components.

The independently owned My Excellent Pet owns and operates its personal manufacturing amenities situated in Sulphur Springs, Texas. The corporate makes use of U.S.-sourced components aside from lamb from New Zealand or Australia, and coconut oil from the Philippines. My Excellent Pet goals to advertise sustainability with the collection of components and all packaging supplies are recyclable.

Recall Historical past

To our information, My Excellent Pet has by no means been recalled. That is vital, provided that the corporate was based within the wake of the most important pet meals recall in historical past.

What Type of Cat Meals Does My Excellent Pet Provide?

My Excellent Pet presents a restricted collection of recent pet meals for each canines and cats. Whereas the pet food product line contains a number of flavors and recipes for a number of life levels, My Excellent Pet’s cat meals line solely contains the next two recipes:

• Toby’s Turkey Carnivore Mix for Cats & Kittens
• Low Phosphorus Rooster Carnivore Mix for Cats

Toby’s Turkey Carnivore mix is formulated in response to AAFCO nutrient profiles for cats of all life levels (together with kittens). It’s the one full and balanced cat meals product My Excellent Pet presently has to supply. The second recipe is meant for supplemental feeding solely, formulated with lower-than-average phosphorus ranges to help kidney well being.

Each of My Excellent Pet’s cat meals formulation are made with human-grade components and ready in FDA-inspected human meals amenities. They’re cooked at average temperatures to protect the dietary integrity of the uncooked components then portioned into 4-ounce bars and frozen. You possibly can solely buy the meals in 3-pound packing containers containing 12 individually wrapped bars of frozen cat meals.

What Did Our Check Cats Suppose?

Kirsten McCarthy / Cats.com

To check My Excellent Pet with my very own cat, I ordered each recipes: Toby’s Turkey and Low Phosphorus Rooster. The meals is available in packs of individually wrapped bars that should be saved frozen to remain recent till feeding, which may very well be inconvenient for these with low freezer area. Nevertheless, they’re condensed fairly flat and never very cumbersome in comparison with another frozen merchandise.

As soon as thawed, they each have a moist and meaty texture. The excessive protein content material with no fillers permits for a extremely nutritious meal mimicking what cats would eat naturally. I might inform that my cat Oliver was fortunately getting a style for his wild facet whereas consuming. He was curious to strive each recipes, however most popular the rooster.

My Excellent Pet Cat Meals—High Recipes Reviewed

What Do Prospects Consider My Excellent Pet Cat Meals?

Exterior of some detailed opinions posted on impartial pet web sites, opinions for My Excellent Pet merchandise seem like restricted to the corporate’s web site. Even there, nonetheless, each cat meals merchandise have lower than 10 opinions. My Excellent Pet additionally posts a restricted variety of testimonials on the positioning, however they look like restricted to opinions written by canine house owners.

My Excellent Pet does have a presence on social media—greater than 30,000 followers on Fb and greater than 6,000 on Instagram—however opinions on these platforms are sparse and largely outdated. The one product opinions on My Excellent Pet’s web site have been posted throughout the final three months, so it’s doable the model moderates opinions earlier than posting them, probably solely permitting 4- and 5-star scores to undergo.

Optimistic Evaluations

Happy clients appear happy with the standard of the components in My Excellent Pet cat meals and infrequently remark that their cats benefit from the merchandise. A number of opinions deal with options that make the model distinctive: providing a totally chicken-free formulation and one low in phosphorus.

“My cat Riley was identified with early-stage kidney illness.  We wished to get him on an excellent weight loss program to assist restore his kidneys to good functioning. Together with uncooked low phosphorus meals was a key focus. The My Excellent Pet Cat Low Phosphorus Rooster frozen bars match the invoice.  Riley likes this meals, and it stays a main a part of his nutritious diet.”—Jean T. reviewing My Excellent Pet Low Phosphorus Rooster Carnivore Mix on October 8, 2024

“Wow, lastly a human grade meals that doesn’t have rooster, peas and oats which my man is extraordinarily allergic too. Did I point out that he completely goes nuts for his meals.”—Steven M. reviewing My Excellent Pet Toby’s Turkey Carnivore Mix on September 10, 2024

Detrimental Evaluations

It was tough to search out detrimental opinions of My Excellent Pet merchandise, largely as a result of there aren’t many opinions posted on-line. The one current detrimental overview I used to be capable of finding appeared to be written by a buyer who was confused both about the right way to serve the frozen meals or how a lot of it their cat ought to be consuming.

“What’s my cat purported to do? Eat the bar??”—Wendy J. reviewing My Excellent Pet Low Phosphorus Rooster Carnivore Mix on June 11, 2024

How A lot Does My Excellent Pet Cat Meals Value?

Kirsten McCarthy / Cats.com

My Excellent Pet recent cat meals is simply offered in 3-pound packing containers. Every field comprises 60 individually wrapped bars of frozen meals weighing 4 ounces every. While you buy via the model’s web site, you might have the choice to make a one-time buy or begin a subscription. There isn’t a low cost for beginning a subscription, however you’ll get free delivery. In any other case, delivery prices round $25.

Each My Excellent Pet cat meals recipes promote for $224 per field which averages out to $0.93 per ounce. This makes it just a little costlier than a few of the hottest recent cat meals manufacturers like Smalls and Simply Meals for Cats, and even some uncooked frozen cat meals manufacturers like Viva.

The estimated each day value to feed a 10-pound cat My Excellent Pet’s solely nutritionally full cat meals is about $3.50. The opposite product is for supplemental feeding solely however prices the identical worth per ounce.

The place Is My Excellent Pet Cat Meals Bought?

The one place to buy My Excellent Pet cat meals on-line is thru the model’s web site. Right here you’ll be able to place a one-time order or begin a recurring subscription. Subscriptions vary from weekly deliveries to deliveries made each 20 weeks.

You might also have the ability to buy My Excellent Pet cat meals in-store for those who dwell in sure states. The meals is simply offered in native and impartial retail shops however areas are unfold out throughout the US. The states with the most important variety of retailers are California and Texas. You possibly can seek for a location close to you utilizing the model’s retailer locator.

Total, Is My Excellent Pet Cat Meals a Good Selection?

Although costlier than many recent cat meals in the marketplace, My Excellent Pet seems to be definitely worth the worth. The draw back is there’s just one nutritionally full recipe out there for cats, so it won’t be the only option in case your cat is allergic or delicate to turkey.

It’s additionally a giant dedication to purchase a 3-pound field for greater than $200 for those who’re undecided your cat will just like the meals. My Excellent Pet does provide a refund coverage—you’ll be able to return the meals inside 5 days of receiving it. Nevertheless, the meals should be frozen and it’s important to select in a single day delivery, which the firm factors out may exceed the price of the meals.

One profit My Excellent Pet has over another common recent meals firms is that it seems to be broadly stocked in shops throughout the nation. If you wish to see the meals before you purchase it (or save your self the price of delivery), you’re more likely to discover it in most main cities.

Comparable Manufacturers

In search of different cat meals manufacturers much like My Excellent Pet? Try a few of our different model opinions.