Score
- Meat is the primary ingredient – 1 Star
- Makes use of some unnamed meats – 1 Star
- Above common protein content material – 0 Star
- Lower than 4 controversial components – 0 Star
- Catological Discretionary Score – 0 Star
2 issues particular to this model of meals earlier than we get began, which we additionally lined in our assessment of the dry meals.
- It is a prescription weight loss program, which you’ll be able to solely purchase with a prescription from a veterinarian. You should purchase prescription meals from Chewy.com, however might want to present proof of prescription.
- The Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan consists of an enormous number of meals supposedly designed to assist with very particular illnesses. We shall be combining all of them into this assessment, as a result of they’re all fairly related, and sadly, they’re all very low high quality. You’ll be taught extra under.
Right here’s a couple of necessary factors:
- Meat is the primary ingredient
- By-products and filler components are utilized in abundance
- Protein is usually very low, and carbohydrates are usually very excessive
- Consists of added nutritional vitamins and minerals
- Whereas the recipes declare to be good for various illnesses, in actuality every recipe is low high quality and stuffed with biologically inappropriate components
Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan product line consists of 28 moist recipes/flavors.
Every recipe under consists of its associated AAFCO nutrient profile when obtainable on the product’s official webpage or packaging: Development (G), Upkeep (M), All Life Phases (A), Supplemental (S) or Unspecified (U).
The star ranking is a tough common of all the flavors in a single line of meals. If a person recipe scored decrease or increased, we’ll mark that under, subsequent to the flavour.
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Urinary Care c/d Hen (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Urinary Care c/d Hen & Vegetable (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Urinary Care c/d Vegetable, Tuna & Rice (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Urinary Care c/d Ocean Fish (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Urinary Care c/d Stress Hen & Vegetable (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Urinary Care s/d Hen (A)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Kidney Care okay/d Hen & Vegetable (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Kidney Care okay/d Vegetable & Tuna (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Kidney Care okay/d Pate with Hen (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Kidney Care okay/d Pate with Tuna (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan okay/d + Mobility Hen & Vegetable (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Kidney Care okay/d Early Assist Hen, Vegetable & Rice (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Digestive Care i/d Hen (G, M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Digestive Care i/d Hen & Vegetable (G, M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Digestive + Weight Administration w/d Hen (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Pores and skin/Meals Sensitivities z/d Unique (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Pores and skin/Meals Sensitivities d/d Duck (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Pressing Care a/d Hen (S)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Thyroid Care y/d Hen (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Glucose/Weight Administration m/d Pork (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Metabolic + Urinary Vegetable & Hen (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Metabolic + Urinary Vegetable & Tuna (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Metabolic Hen (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Metabolic Vegetable & Hen (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Metabolic Vegetable & Tuna (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Weight Discount r/d Hen (S)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Growing older Care g/d Turkey (M)
- Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Joint Care j/d Hen (M)
Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Pores and skin/Meals Sensitivities d/d Duck was chosen to symbolize the opposite merchandise within the line for this assessment.
Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Pores and skin/Meals Sensitivies d/d Duck
Moist Cat Meals
| Estimated Nutrient Content material |
| Protein | Fats | Carbs | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Assured Evaluation | 8% | 5.5% | NA |
| Dry Matter Foundation | 36% | 25% | 20% |
| Calorie Weighted Foundation | 31% | 52% | 17% |
Estimated Dry Matter Nutrient Content material
Fiber (assured evaluation)
2%
Is actual, named meat the primary ingredient?
Sure
Elements
Water, Duck, Duck Liver, Floor Inexperienced Pea, Powdered Cellulose, Soybean Oil, Pea Protein Focus, Brewers Dried Yeast, Fish Oil, Glucose, Calcium Carbonate, DL-Methionine, Dicalcium Phosphate, Taurine, L-Cystine, Choline Chloride, Iron Oxide, Glycine, Potassium Chloride, Iodized Salt, Vitamin E Complement, Potassium Citrate, Thiamine Mononitrate, Ascorbic Acid (supply of Vitamin C), Zinc Oxide, Ferrous Sulfate, Thiamine Hydrochloride, Niacin, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Beta-Carotene, Manganous Oxide, Calcium Pantothenate, Vitamin B12 Complement, Riboflavin, Biotin, Vitamin D3 Complement, Calcium Iodate, Folic Acid, Sodium Selenite.
Elements in pink are controversial or of questionable high quality.
Ingredient Breakdown
After water, the primary ingredient on this cat meals is duck. Good.
Whereas high quality of the person ingredient can range, duck is an effective protein supply for cats.
It’s additionally necessary to notice that duck accommodates about 70% water, so when it’s processed and cooked to be used in cat meals, it would turn out to be a smaller a part of the overall recipe.
The second ingredient is duck liver. Good.
Liver is a crucial organ meat that your cat would eat within the wild to get further protein, nutritional vitamins, and minerals.
That is often an indication of a top quality meals.
The third ingredient is floor inexperienced pea. Dangerous.
Peas are a high quality carbohydrate for people, however cats don’t want a lot in the way in which of carbohydrates.
They’re stuffed with fiber, but additionally comprise a good quantity of protein, which we should always take into account when judging the meat content material of this meals.
Peas are biologically inappropriate for cats, and there doesn’t have to be any in right here.
The fourth ingredient is powdered cellulose. Dangerous.
It is a filler excessive in insoluble fiber.
It’s usually wooden pulp (sawdust) from pine bushes.
An excessive amount of insoluble fiber can intrude with digestion and inhibit protein and nutrient uptake.
The fifth ingredient is soybean oil. Dangerous.
Soy is a nasty ingredient for cats, significantly soy manufactured in factories within the US, the place soy bean protein is used to create different merchandise, in comparison with Asia, the place soy is usually fermented, which makes it significantly better for the physique.
Soy accommodates many anti-nutrients that inhibits your cat’s physique from digesting vitamins from the opposite meals she eats.
The sixth ingredient is pea protein focus. Dangerous.
This ingredient is a concentrated type of the protein present in peas, which suggests the precise meat content material of this meals could also be decrease than the macronutrient profile suggests. It’s a protein booster.
Peas usually are not the worst carbohydrate your cat can devour, however they’re merely under no circumstances biologically applicable.
The seventh ingredient is brewer’s dried yeast. Dangerous.
A by-product of brewing beer, it’s used for flavoring and for protein and B-vitamins.
Nonetheless, some experiences counsel that it may turn out to be very poisonous to the liver, inflicting allergy symptoms and arthritis, in giant doses.
This recipe consists of various different components, however when you get down this far, none of them shall be in giant sufficient portions to make an actual distinction, aside from the added nutritional vitamins and minerals.
Nonetheless, there are nonetheless a couple of issues you must know.
Glucose is sugar, and isn’t applicable ingredient for felines. It might trigger weight problems and probably even diabetes.
Iron oxide is used to paint the meals and provides it a extra pink, meaty colour.
Since it’s 100% advertising gimmick, it’s pointless, and often the signal of an inexpensive cat meals.
They’re possible fairly protected, not absorbed into the physique, and sure non-toxic, however any coloring additive is questionable, and iron oxide has not been studied as a meals additive very totally.
To learn a extra in depth article about any of the components listed right here, take a look at our Cat Meals Ingredient Wiki (at present below growth).
The Catological Verdict on Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Moist Cat Meals
From high to backside, this can be a under common moist meals.
Meat is the primary ingredient, however decrease high quality by-products are widespread.
Fillers are used extensively in each recipe, which will increase carbohydrate ranges. Every filler can be biologically inappropriate for a pure feline weight loss program.
Simply because these are prescription-only meals doesn’t imply they’re good.
It’s worrying that any veterinarian would advocate these, when many of the points they declare to resolve will be solved with a pure weight loss program that comes near reaching the macro and micronutrient ranges that cats would eat within the wild.
Don’t be fooled into pondering that these are prime quality, or particular in any means. They don’t comprise particular, medicinal components. They’re low high quality and are prone to do extra hurt than good to your cat.
Protein is simply too low and carbohydrates are too excessive.
That is NOT a superb instance of a moist meals you have to be feeding your cat.
Because it’s clear that plant merchandise make up an excessive amount of of this meals, we are able to assume that this can be a largely plant-based meals, which isn’t superb in your carnivorous feline’s dietary wants.
To assessment, on a dry matter foundation, this meals is 36% protein, 25% fats, and 20% carbs.
As a gaggle, the model has a median protein content material of 37%, and common fats content material of 20%, and a median carb content material of 30%.
In comparison with the opposite 2000+ meals in our database, this meals has:
- Beneath common protein.
- Common fats.
- Above common carbs.
As a result of meat is the primary ingredient, it is filled with fillers, and we don’t consider it’s truthful for a corporation to cost a lot for a low high quality meals, all whereas calling it prescription, as if it’s particular, our ranking for this model is 2 stars.
Not really helpful.
Hill’s Cat Meals Recall Historical past
We don’t consider {that a} recall signifies a low high quality meals or firm, and we respect the truth that typically issues occur that trigger a producer to recall a meals.
Normally these items are non-life-threatening, and we expect it’s necessary to take a second to be grateful about simply how few remembers there actually are within the trade, contemplating the large quantity of meals produced.
Nonetheless, we do consider {that a} historical past of remembers could level to a bigger concern with an organization, and that discerning customers wish to know who they’re shopping for from, particularly in the case of one thing as necessary because the meals you feed the one that you love cat.
Here’s a record of remembers which have affected the Hill’s model prior to now:
- Could 2016 – Excessive iron ranges – UK and Russian merchandise affected
- November 2015 (“Withdrawal”, not Recall) – Labeling points – A number of canine recipes affected
- June 2014 – Attainable salmonella – 1 recipe affected
- April 2007 – Melamine – 1 recipe affected
- March 2007 – Melamine – A number of cat meals recipes affected
If you wish to keep updated on the most recent recall data affecting your cat’s meals, signal as much as our e-mail record and obtain an e-mail each time a recall is introduced. We’ll additionally let you recognize about any up to date scores, recipe modifications, or new cat meals available on the market. (Our alert system shall be launched shortly, verify again quickly.)
The place To Purchase Hill’s Prescription Weight-reduction plan Moist Cat Meals
We advocate buying your pet merchandise from Chewy.com. They frequently show that they stroll the stroll whereas speaking the discuss, and I’ve by no means handled a extra devoted pet-parent base of individuals than those that work at Chewy.
Plus, they provide 20% off and free delivery on numerous orders.
Not Satisfied?
Try our scores and evaluations of the perfect cat meals in our complete, data-backed information proper right here.
