Kate Barrington / Cats.com
Lucy Pet Merchandise gives “formulation for all times” and gross sales of the meals help the mission of the Lucy Pet Basis. However is the meals worthy of constructing it into your cat’s bowl? Discover out on this detailed evaluation of Lucy Pet cat meals.
The Cats.com Customary—Score Lucy Pet on What Issues
We’ve analyzed Lucy Pet and graded it in response to the Cats.com normal. Right here’s the way it charges in every of six key areas:
Scores
- Species-Appropriateness – 8/10
- Ingredient High quality – 8/10
- Product Selection – 6/10
- Value – 6/10
- Buyer Expertise – 7/10
- Recall Historical past – 10/10
General Rating: 7.5/10
We give Lucy Pet cat meals a forty five out of 60 ranking or a B+ grade.
Why Belief Cats.com
Once we evaluation cat meals manufacturers, we begin by performing intensive analysis into the corporate’s historical past and its place inside the business. Our specialists delve into the model’s ingredient sourcing and manufacturing practices, reaching out to the corporate immediately when such data isn’t available. We additionally learn evaluations to get a really feel for buyer satisfaction with the model and to study what potential issues to remember when performing our personal in-house testing.
The complete evaluation course of is funded by Cats.com with no direct affect from the manufacturers we evaluation. This course of entails in-depth evaluation of a number of cat meals merchandise in addition to real-world testing with our personal cats. We consider particular person merchandise on their dietary deserves and depend on our cats’ opinions to evaluate metrics like taste and common attraction.
About Lucy Pet
Lucy Pet Merchandise was based in 2015 by Joey Herrick who drew inspiration from his rescue canine, a chihuahua combine named Lucy. However Lucy Pet Meals wasn’t the primary firm created in Lucy’s identify—and even Herrick’s first pet meals firm. Herrick can also be the founding father of Pure Stability Pet Meals and of the Lucy Pet Basis.
The Lucy Pet Basis is a registered 501(c)(3) animal charity with a mission to assist scale back pet overpopulation. By cell spay/neuter/adoption mobiles, the Basis has carried out over 30,000 free spay and neuter procedures all through Southern California. The Basis additionally hosts free vaccination occasions and helps native animal rescues.
Lucy Pet Merchandise was launched to assist fund the Lucy Pet Basis, which is why Herrick refers to Lucy Pet meals as “merchandise with a trigger.” Lucy Pet dry cat meals merchandise are formulated to help wholesome digestion and pure immunity, that includes prebiotic fiber in each recipes. The model’s moist meals are designed to imitate selfmade meals with a chunks-in-gravy texture and loads of animal-sourced protein.
Sourcing and Manufacturing
Lucy Pet Merchandise relies in Westlake Village in California, USA. The merchandise are manufactured and distributed by Breeder’s Selection Pet Meals, LLC with globally sourced elements. Breeder’s Selection is a pet meals producer with over 75 years of historical past within the business. It’s presently owned by a gaggle of Southern California traders, together with Joey Herrick.
Based on the corporate’s web site, Lucy Pet’s vitamin crew consists of professionals from the pet business with a mixed 200 years of expertise in canine and feline vitamin. The web site mentions a Twin Ph.D. Nutritionist Formulation Staff in addition to “Protected High quality Meals (SQF) Degree 2” Licensed Ingredient Sourcing Specialists.
Not solely are Lucy Pet merchandise formulated and made in company-owned kitchens, however every batch is rigorously examined to make sure it meets the assured evaluation and is free from pathogens and contaminants.
Recall Historical past
To our information, Lucy Pet cat meals has by no means been recalled. Prospects can entry the protection lab take a look at outcomes for particular batches utilizing the product code on the label at PetFoodSafetyLab.com.
What Type of Cat Meals Does Lucy Pet Supply?
Kate Barrington / Cats.com
Lucy Pet gives a wide range of canine and cat meals merchandise, although the choice of cat meals is the extra restricted of the 2. The cat meals line doesn’t embody recent meals rolls just like the pet food line, nevertheless it does embody dry cat meals, moist cat meals, and lickable cat treats.
There are two Lucy Pet dry cat meals recipes to select from, each of that are marketed as restricted ingredient formulation. One recipe is grain-inclusive, that includes hen and brown rice as fundamental elements. The opposite is grain-free, made with salmon and quinoa. Each recipes include a number of animal proteins and are enriched with prebiotic fiber to help a wholesome intestine microbiome.
Lucy Pet’s moist cat meals line known as Kettle Creations and consists of the next formulation:
- Rooster Recipe in Gravy
- Rooster and Duck Recipe in Gravy
- Sardine and Tuna Recipe in Gravy
- Salmon and Rooster Recipe in Gravy
All 4 of Lucy Pet’s moist cat meals recipes include pumpkin as a supply of fiber and all however one include brown rice. Solely the hen recipe is a single-protein components, although the Sardine and Tuna recipe seems to be fish-only (it doesn’t include hen elements).
What Did Our Check Cats Suppose?
Kate Barrington / Cats.com
To check Lucy Pet Meals, I bought the Kitty Coronary heart Bowl Sampler by way of the Lucy Pet Merchandise web site. This pattern pack consists of two 2-ounce pattern luggage of each dry meals formulation, three 2.47-ounce (70g) cans of moist meals, and an orange fiesta ware heart-shaped bowl. Although not listed on the product web page, I additionally acquired a pattern of every of Lucy Pet’s lickable cat treats.
My sampler pack arrived pretty shortly and I used to be shocked to search out it properly wrapped, like a present basket. I used to be significantly happy to search out the heart-shaped bowl is sturdy and the correct measurement and depth for my cats to eat from simply. It’s additionally very simple to wash.
Although I solely reviewed three recipes in-depth beneath, I examined all of the merchandise I acquired with my two cats, Biscuit and Munchkin. Biscuit loved the moist meals which had a chunky texture with loads of liquid. The lickable cat treats have been Munchkin’s favourite from Lucy Pet.
Lucy Pet Cat Meals—Prime 3 Recipes Reviewed
What Do Prospects Consider Lucy Pet Cat Meals?
Whereas Lucy Pet has been round for a few decade, it doesn’t have a powerful on-line presence. This can be as a result of the model relies in Southern California and solely offered domestically in shops.
On-line evaluations are sparse with most cat meals merchandise having fewer than 50 scores on Chewy and fewer than 100 scores on Amazon. The exception is Lucy Pet’s salmon recipe dry cat meals which had over 800 scores on Amazon on the time of this evaluation.
Optimistic Critiques
Glad clients often touch upon the standard of Lucy Pet cat meals, some saying the upper price ticket is price it for his or her cats. A number of clients point out improved digestion on Lucy Pet dry cat meals and others approve of the quantity of moisture within the moist meals.
“Considered one of my ferals has had severe bowel points since she got here into my care… The final bout of points got here with horrible diarrhea and bloody stool. I did all the things, from antibiotics to probiotics to freeze dried meals. Nothing helped. I discovered this meals, and figured the pumpkin may assist. It did!! Her stool was fully agency inside every week of getting this meals.” – Christina reviewing Lucy Pet Rooster, Brown Rice & Pumpkin dry cat meals on Chewy.com, April 13, 2024
“This model was given at no cost on the native adoption heart, however we continued to feed our cats at residence with this meals… The standard of the elements is high notch for the worth for cash. I believe the cats have a better time digesting this meals, and provides them the required power they want.” – Ryan reviewing Lucy Pet Rooster, Brown Rice & Pumpkin dry cat meals on Amazon.com, Might 30, 2024
Unfavorable Critiques
Dissatisfied clients often remark that their cats merely weren’t excited by Lucy Pet meals. A number of evaluations point out that the dry meals goes stale shortly, so this might account for its low attraction in some instances. Unfavorable evaluations of Lucy Pet moist cat meals typically point out inconsistent texture between batches and the excessive value of the meals.
“Lucy dry meals is so nice I had excessive hopes for the moist meals. It’s all broth, not a lot meat. Cats weren’t . So disappointing.” – Heidi Zysk reviewing Lucy Pet Rooster and Duck moist cat meals on Amazon.com, Might 23, 2024
“My cats aren’t tremendous choosy, however they only sniff the Lucy model dry meals and gained’t eat it. We tried it for six meals once they have been meowing that they have been hungry however have no real interest in this meals.” – Tumblewind reviewing Lucy Pet Salmon, Pumpkin & Quinoa dry cat meals on Amazon.com, February 20, 2024
How A lot Does Lucy Pet Cat Meals Price?
Lucy Pet is marketed as a premium pet meals model and its costs replicate that. In the event you purchase immediately from Lucy Pet, you’ll pay $20.99 for a case of 12 cans of moist cat meals. This averages out to about $0.71 per ounce. It can save you 5% with an autoship order.
As with many cat meals manufacturers, Lucy Pet dry cat meals price considerably much less per ounce than moist cat meals. You’ll get the most effective value on Lucy Pet dry meals by shopping for the 10-pound versus 4-pound bag. Costs differ on completely different retailers however, on the model’s web site, a 10-pound bag of dry meals prices $39.99 (about $0.25 per ounce).
Utilizing the instance of a 10-pound cat with a day by day calorie requirement of 200 energy, the estimated feeding price for Lucy Pet cat meals could be about $0.50 per day for dry meals and about $6.50 for moist meals.
The place Is Lucy Pet Cat Meals Bought?
The complete lineup of Lucy Pet merchandise is on the market for buy immediately from the model and from a number of main on-line pet retailers. Whereas you should buy any of Lucy Pet’s cat meals on Chewy.com or Amazon.com, the pattern packs are solely offered on the model’s web site. You too can buy bundles of dry cat meals luggage on the Lucy Pet web site.
Lucy Pet merchandise are additionally offered in shops however largely in Southern California close to the corporate’s Irwindale plant. To see if Lucy Pet cat meals is offered in a retailer close to you, use the Retailer Locator on the Lucy Pet web site.
General, Is Lucy Pet Cat Meals a Good Selection?
Marketed as a super-premium pet meals line, Lucy Pet merchandise don’t distinguish themselves in opposition to a few of the extra economically priced manufacturers we’ve reviewed. The dry meals are respectable for the worth level however the taste appears fairly hit-or-miss with cats. Lucy Pet moist meals are far more costly and are much less biologically preferrred than you may count on on the value.
What does set Lucy Pet other than many manufacturers is that gross sales help a superb trigger—the Lucy Pet Basis’s efforts to assist scale back pet overpopulation. This model may take advantage of sense for cat house owners who dwell in Southern California and can buy the merchandise domestically (and possibly even profit from a few of the Lucy Pet Basis’s programming themselves).
Usually talking, Lucy Pet merchandise are definitely higher than low cost manufacturers like Friskies and Fancy Feast. However you might be able to discover one thing of comparable or larger high quality at a cheaper price level.
Related Manufacturers
On the lookout for different cat meals manufacturers much like Lucy Pet? Take a look at a few of our different model evaluations.
