What Did Scientists Study After Hundreds of Penguins Had been Slaughtered by Mountain Lions?

In 2007, solely three years after the creation of Monte León Nationwide Park alongside the wild shoreline of Argentine Patagonia, efforts to guard penguins took an sudden flip. A feminine puma was slaughtering Magellanic penguins in droves. A few of these she would eat, whereas different surplus kills had been left to rot. Earlier than lengthy, her cubs joined within the feast. All instructed, the household doubtless killed hundreds of penguins over the course of some nesting seasons.

Conservationists had been shocked—what might have occurred? Certainly these sorts of assaults didn’t happen up to now. The park was created, at the very least partly, to guard the massive penguin colony, which numbers within the tens of hundreds. The aquatic birds even function prominently on the park’s brand.

Wildlife managers stepped in to place a cease to the killing. “They lastly determined to sacrifice these animals to guard penguins,” says Javier Ciancio, a marine biologist and ecologist with Argentina’s Nationwide Scientific and Technical Analysis Council.

However new analysis revealed in December 2024 within the Journal for Nature Conservation by Ciancio and his colleagues reveals that this type of predation doubtless did happen up to now—and it might be why there as soon as weren’t so many penguin colonies on the mainland of South America. That doubtless modified roughly a century in the past, when an inflow of sheep farmers led to the extirpation of most land-based predators, and the rise of whaling and the fur commerce might have severely decreased marine predators. The long-term ecological penalties of those human interventions might have set the scene for an explosion in mainland penguin populations.

“[Penguins] are occupying a bigger space because of eradicating the puma and different predators,” Ciancio says. “That’s the paradox of dwelling within the anthropogenized world.”

Of their research, Ciancio and his colleagues examined the significance of penguins within the weight loss plan of the 4 pumas that tore by the colony at Monte León. In addition they explored the historical past of this species of penguin.

As Ciancio and his colleagues be aware within the paper, most seabirds—Magellanic penguins included—solely breed in colonies on small offshore islands, or often in rugged cliffsides on the mainland. These sorts of roosts are principally free from land-based predators, which might in any other case make fast work of nests, chicks and even adults, given penguins’ clumsiness on their ft. The Magellanic penguins nest on islands offshore from the mainland coast in South America in addition to farther-flung islands just like the Falklands. However up to now century or so, they more and more nest in massive colonies on the mainland of South America. Their nesting colonies could be huge, numbering within the lots of of hundreds, normally on comparatively flat seashores.

Most Magellanic penguin nest colonies on South America’s mainland are comparatively new—particularly the actually massive ones similar to these at Punta Tombo and Península Valdés in Argentina. Whereas some proof exists that penguins at Punta Tombo had been within the space within the Miocene Epoch, hundreds of thousands of years in the past, the colony there appears to have disappeared till at the very least 1876, when fowl surveys didn’t point out any of the aquatic birds. Dee Boersma, a biologist on the College of Washington, and her colleagues write that penguins doubtless colonized Punta Tombo within the Twenties. The inhabitants remained small till the mid-Nineteen Forties, when it started to broaden quickly in numbers. In the meantime, different colonies close by in all probability started up to now century or in order nicely, together with the large one at Península Valdés.

Boersma and her staff have been finding out the Punta Tombo colony for many years. In a research revealed in 1990 within the ebook Penguin Biology, she and her colleagues be aware that the breeding distribution seems to be transferring northward as circumstances improved for the species. Colonies round Puerto Madryn similar to that at Península Valdés and Punta Tombo now quantity within the lots of of hundreds.

Ciancio says penguins at Monte León might have thrived for the century main as much as current a long time due to a scarcity of pumas within the space. A number of the first settlers in coastal Argentine Patagonia had been sheep farmers. To higher shield their herds, they eradicated all potential predators within the space, together with pumas, foxes and smaller endemic wild cats. To extirpate mountain lions from their farms, settlers used a mix of poison, which might have killed not solely pumas however different smaller potential predators, and lioneros—specialists at looking down and killing pumas. “We’ve develop into very efficient in eradicating pumas,” Ciancio says.

By eradicating predators that would have feasted on penguin nests, chicks and even adults, the farmers principally opened up extra appropriate penguin nesting habitat alongside the coast, permitting penguins to both broaden in inhabitants or vary, or shift their nesting areas from offshore islands to mainland seashores that could be nearer to good forage fish assets.

“The farmer poisoning to kill pumas by no means would have thought he’d affect the bigger marine ecosystem,” Ciancio says. The Patagonian coast of Argentina doesn’t have many offshore islands, locations the place penguins might nest secure from predators. “Offering the chance to breed on the mainland has opened up new habitat.”

The difficulty is, for the penguins at the very least, the arid circumstances of coastal Patagonia in Argentina aren’t superb for sheep herding in the long term. Sheep and different varieties of farming shortly degrade the soil, and excessive winds within the space then blow away a lot of what’s left. By the Nineteen Nineties, most of the shepherds had left the world consequently.

The federal government moved to guard among the penguin colonies, creating nationwide parks like Monte León. However this will likely have been counterproductive, at the very least for the penguin colonies. The shortage of sheep farmers and new safety afforded by nationwide parks meant pumas, foxes and different predators had been not killed. In some instances, they’ve returned to coastal areas, the place they prey on penguins.

In accordance with steady isotope evaluation carried out by Ciancio and his colleagues on the 4 pumas at Monte León, their weight loss plan modified from principally counting on terrestrial meals to 1 that just about totally relied on penguins. On prime of this, Ciancio notes that pumas, like different cats, typically kill many extra prey than they’ll eat. “A puma can kill lots of of penguins whereas feeding on solely a fraction of them,” he says.

Ciancio provides that pumas might have an effect on penguins in the long run. “Predation is especially necessary when the colony is within the early phases of formation,” he says. “This might occur at any time on the continent, however after predation occasions, penguins might select to nest elsewhere, in safer places similar to islands.”

Katie Holt, a graduate scholar in biology on the College of Washington who works with Boersma at Punta Tombo however wasn’t concerned in Ciancio’s research, agrees with Ciancio’s discovering that when farmers eliminated the pumas and different massive predators, they doubtless allowed penguins to nest. “Eradicating predators have now allowed this very charismatic seabird to maneuver in,” she says.

However she doesn’t suppose that pumas could have a big impression on penguin colonies, even when they arrive in and kill 100 or so at a time in surplus killing, as a result of vastness of those colonies, which may quantity within the lots of of hundreds.

She additionally says different elements doubtless helped the penguins discover colonial buy on the mainland a few century in the past. For instance, Boersma famous in her 1990 research a number of potential causes for the growing vary of penguins on the mainland in South America, together with a lower in competitors for forage fish after the decimation of whales within the early twentieth century. Seals and sea lions—predators of penguins and meals opponents—had been additionally closely harvested within the mid-1900s. Indigenous individuals used to reap penguins, however they not reside alongside a lot of the coast resulting from colonial persecution. Local weather change over the previous century might have modified the productiveness sample of penguin prey as nicely, making meals extra considerable for penguins in some areas than it was once.

Ciancio’s analysis wasn’t solely centered on the previous. His staff modeled the best way that penguins would possibly have an effect on the inhabitants of anchovies off the coast. Through the use of present penguin inhabitants numbers to estimate what number of forage fish these penguins had been doubtless consuming, the staff revealed that, within the areas penguins feed, they doubtless eat greater than the fishing fleet captures. “The consumption right now is greater than the entire fisheries manufacturing,” Ciancio says.

This creates a conservation paradox, Ciancio says, the place wildlife managers might must make powerful choices. “What ought to we do when human intervention, just like the eradication of terrestrial predators, advantages charismatic species like penguins however comes on the expense of much less charismatic pure assets, similar to forage fish and associated marine meals webs?” he and his coauthors write within the paper.

Whereas penguins could also be consuming lots, Holt isn’t positive the general impact on forage fish is any completely different from centuries earlier, when marine mammals like whales, seals or sea lions doubtless would have taken a bigger share. “Earlier than there have been many penguins nesting on the coast, there have been doubtless many different prime predators feeding on forage fish,” she says.

However troublesome questions come up as to how wildlife managers ought to take care of the state of affairs on the coast. For instance, ought to park managers introduce or welcome pumas into coastal nationwide parks to cut back the impression of penguins on fishing shares? Or ought to pumas be taken out to protect populations of the charismatic birds?

As Ciancio and his colleagues ask within the paper, “Which species maintain essentially the most ecological worth in these ecosystems?”

This article by Joshua Rapp Study was first revealed by The Smithsonian on 13 February 2025. Lead Picture: Magellanic penguin colony at Isla Magdalena, Chile. Round 120,000 magellanic penguins (Spheniscus magellanicus) nest in burrows on the island. This medium-sized penguin inhabits the coasts of Chile, Argentina and the Falkland Islands. It reaches a mean size of 70 centimetres. The magellanic penguin feeds on fish, cephalopods (similar to squid), crustaceans and krill, looking in teams. Photographed on Isla Magdalena, Chile. Photograph by PETER J. RAYMOND / SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY.

We create consciousness by articles, social media and petitions, bringing wildlife points to the eye of governments, influential organizations and determination makers.

We help main wildlife charities by promoting, ad-free subscriptions and your beneficiant donations.

What you are able to do

Assist to save lots of wildlife by donating as little as $1 – It solely takes a minute.